|

|
We encourage you to develop additional lessons to supplement Regret
to Inform, and to share these with
other teachers on the website. Below are the outlines of some
follow-up activities.
- Additional questions.
If you decide to show this film as an introduction to a longer unit
on Vietnam, use it to generate a list of questions that students want
to pursue about the war. Use these questions to guide your inquiry.
- Letter writing.
Have students read the letters that Barbara Sonneborn wrote Jeff Gurvitz,
twenty years after he was killed. Allow them to write a letter to a
loved one who has died. Sonneborn's letters are posted on the web at
www.pbs.org/pov/regret/bg_barb.html.
- Agent Orange.
Norma Banks' husband died of the effects of Agent Orange poisoning.
As she says in the film, "Sometimes the effects of a war don't
happen right away." Encourage students to research the lingering
effects of Agent Orangeon Vietnam vets, and on the people and
environment of Vietnam. Ask students to think of how they might be able
to make a difference on this issue.
- Land mines.
Land mines continue to maim and kill in Southeast Asiaindeed the
area where Jeff Gurvitz was killed is still infested with mines. Encourage
students to learn more about the global movement to ban landmines and
about solidarity efforts to help rid regions of mines. See the excellent
video, Arms for the Poor, available from the Teaching
for Change catalog, www.teachingforchange.org.
- Herbicides/defoliation.
Encourage students to research the use of herbicides in the escalating
war in Colombia. As of the writing of this guide in early 2001, the
United States government is providing Colombia with large amounts of
broad-spectrum herbicidespoisons which kill anything that's greento
spray over vast stretches of the countryside, including fragile rainforests.
The alleged aim is to stamp out coca production in the country.
- Memorial.
Tell students that they have been given the task of constructing a memorial
to the womenboth Vietnamese and Americanwho were affected
by the war between the United States and Vietnam. Have them work in
small groups to design this memorial.
- Trial.
Organize a trial to address the "crime" of the killing of
Jeff Gurvitz: Who killed Jeff Gurvitz? If we are to prevent
future Jeffs from dying, then this is a vital question. Assign students
to represent various "defendants": the U.S. government,
for ordering Jeff to war; the schools Jeff attended, for not
teaching him the history of the war, which might have led him to question
the U.S. role there; Jeff himself, for choosing to go into the
armed forces even though he knew that he might have to kill or be killed
in a war he didn't necessarily agree with or even understand; the
"Viet Cong," for attacking Jeff's unit; Racism,
for being a key attitudinal "virus" that infected American
consciousness and allowed for, if not caused, the war; the Capitalist
Systemthe first factor listed by historian Marilyn Young in
summarizing the origins of the war. As she writes, "[T]he war grew
out of the necessities of maintaining a global capitalist system, of
the daily specifics of decision making, of the requirementsindividual
and nationalfor 'credibility' as defined by men who played zero
sum games against a demonized communist Other. And for these reasons
so many died." Because students tend to personalize blame, it's
especially important in trial activities such as this that at least
one "defendant" role prompts students to think systemicallyto
reflect on the extent to which individuals' actions can best be understood
In the trial, the teacher plays the prosecutor and students in small
groups, the defendants.
[For a model of this
kind of a trial role play, that also includes a "system" role,
see "The Trial of Columbus," pp. 87-94 in Rethinking
Columbus, Bill Bigelow and Bob Peterson, eds. 2nd edition, Rethinking
Schools, 1998.]
- Children's books.
Have students write and illustrate children's books on one or more of
the women's stories in Regret to Inform or other aspects
of the war. Help them make arrangements to take these to elementary
schools to read to the children there and to lead discussions. Obviously,
many of these may be inappropriate for small children. Nonetheless,
I've found that the attempt to write children's books on difficult subjects
helps students decide what is most essential and to explain themselves
clearly.
- Metaphorical drawings.
Students can use imagery and language from the film, and/or from their
own writing on the film, to construct metaphorical drawings. For example,
Diane Van Renselaar says that her husband imagined a navy attack squadron
as a "flying football team." Nguyen Thi Hong says that "The
cruelty that we experienced was longer than a river, higher than a mountain,
deeper than an ocean." Both these descriptions could become metaphorical
drawings. Also ask students what pictures enter their minds as they
think back to the filmthese could spark ideas for metaphorical
drawings.
- Research the "enemy."
Have students assess the tenacity of the U.S. government's Vietnamese
"enemy" by reading from source documentsfor example,
the 1945 Declaration of Independence of Vietnam, speeches of Ho Chi
Minh, documents on the National Liberation Front. An excellent source
for these is Vietnam and America: A Documented History,
edited by Marvin E. Gettleman, Jane Franklin, Marilyn Young, and H.
Bruce Franklin [Grove Press, 1985.] See also Barbara Sonneborn's moving
description of her visit to Que Son, where Jeff was killed, available
on the web, at www.pbs.org/pov/regret/bg_barb.html.
This letter is titled "Khe Sanh."
- Interviews.
Encourage students to use the film to generate interview questions to
ask of Vietnam veterans or of others who are old enough to remember
the war. Have them conduct and write-up the interviews.
- Research "Friendly
fire" as metaphor.
After Barbara Sonneborn completed Regret to Inform, she
received a phone call from someone who had been with her husband Jeff
when he was killed. She learned that, contrary to what she had been
told by the U.S. military, Jeff was not killed by North Vietnamese fire,
but by "friendly fire"a U.S. mortar attack that fell
short of its target. Sonneborn writes, "I was deeply shaken by
this news. Why wasn't I told?" Students digging deeper into the
phenomenon of friendly firea macabre oxymoronwill uncover
important aspects about the nature of the war. For example, many U.S.
officers were killed in fragging incidents, an intentional form of "friendly
fire." Sonneborn urges us to think about the lie that she was told
about her husband's death as an example of "the series of lies"
told to justify and continue the war.
In the film Hearts and Minds, Daniel Ellsberg, of The Pentagon
Papers fame, states that every American president, from Truman through
Nixon, lied about U.S. involvement in Vietnam. He catalogs the variety
of these lies, and remarks that it was a tribute to Americans that their
leaders felt that they had to lie in order to sell the warbut
it was unfortunate that it was so easy for them to get away with it.
Divide students into
five groups representing each of the presidents Ellsberg claimed lied
to the American people: Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson, and Nixon.
Have students research Ellsberg's claim. Each group should attempt to
discover the truthfulness or duplicity of American policymakers during
these five administrations.
|